‘Back To The Future’ Celebrates Its 40th Anniversary After Undergoing Quite The Transformation

As Back to the Future cel­e­brates its 40th anniver­sary, new reflec­tions are sur­fac­ing about one of the film’s most sur­pris­ing behind-the-scenes sto­ries. The 1985 clas­sic almost had a very dif­fer­ent look, with Eric Stoltz orig­i­nal­ly cast as Mar­ty McFly before being replaced by Michael J. Fox. The sud­den switch became one of Hollywood’s most-dis­cussed cast­ing changes

A new report revis­its this piv­otal moment, reveal­ing why direc­tor Robert Zemeck­is and pro­duc­er Steven Spiel­berg felt com­pelled to make the change. Though Stoltz is a respect­ed actor, his por­tray­al report­ed­ly didn’t match the comedic and light-heart­ed tone the film­mak­ers envi­sioned for the movie. After sev­er­al weeks of film­ing, the dif­fi­cult deci­sion was made to recast the role.

Related:

1. Alan Alda Cel­e­brates 40th Anniver­sary Of His­toric ‘M*A*S*H’ Finale
2. See ‘The Mup­pet Movie’ In The­aters For Two Days Only For Its 40th Anniver­sary

Eric Stoltz’s seri­ous approach led to his depar­ture

Eric Stoltz end­ed up tak­ing the role of Mar­ty McFly, if only for a while / Wiki­me­dia Com­mons

Eric Stoltz’s act­ing method clashed with the film’s intend­ed style. Accord­ing to those involved, Stoltz played the char­ac­ter with a dark­er, more seri­ous tone, lean­ing into dra­mat­ic ele­ments that felt out of sync with the movie’s play­ful and adven­tur­ous spir­it. The pro­duc­tion team noticed that scenes lacked the charm and humor they hoped to cap­ture.

Even­tu­al­ly, after con­sult­ing with Spiel­berg, Zemeck­is decid­ed to halt pro­duc­tion and replace Stoltz with Michael J. Fox, who was already star­ring in Fam­i­ly Ties at the time. Though it required reshoot­ing much of the film, the move paid off, as Fox’s ener­getic per­for­mance became cen­tral to the movie’s endur­ing suc­cess.

Michael J. Fox helped define the film’s lega­cy, which is still cel­e­brat­ed as ‘Back to the Future’ cel­e­brates its 40th anniver­sary

YouTube Screen­shot

Bring­ing in Fox dra­mat­i­cal­ly shift­ed the film’s ener­gy. His comedic tim­ing and approach­able charis­ma brought the right blend of humor and heart to Mar­ty McFly, trans­form­ing Back to the Futureinto a glob­al phe­nom­e­non. Cast and crew alike quick­ly saw the dif­fer­ence, as scenes began to come alive in the way the film­mak­ers had orig­i­nal­ly imag­ined.

Now, as fans cel­e­brate the movie’s 40th anniver­sary, many con­tin­ue to won­der how the film might have looked with Stoltz in the lead role. How­ev­er, most agree that Fox’s per­for­mance remains icon­ic and essen­tial to the film’s lega­cy.